Chapter 3244: In Bad Faith
Chapter 3244: In Bad Faith
Date: Unspecified
Time: Unspecified
Location: Myriad Realms, Dark Realm, Seven Prince of Hell Territory, Pandemonium City, Center of Pandemonium Volcano, Millennium Volcano Heart Natural Array, Inter-realm city, Demon Merchant Court.
The moment I finished explaining myself and my actions, the Grand Vizier spoke without delay. "I would direct the Court’s attention to the fact that the respondent stands in breach of a clause within that same contract: Every Merchant is bound by honor to use the Demon Merchant Code’s inter-realm transportation function to enter and leave the Realm of True Evil, and to disclose their haul to the Mulias Imperial Family. No Merchant acting in good faith would fail to do so.
"By departing the Realm of True Evil through unknown means rather than the Code’s inter-realm transportation function, the respondent not only violated this clause but also withheld disclosure of his haul from the Mulias Imperial Family. Thereby, he obstructed the Imperial family from being able to collect the fee he owed to them for access to the Realm of True Evil. In turn he evaded paying the agreed-upon fee for access to the Realm of True Evil through the Demon Merchant Code’s inter-realm transportation function."
I shook my head in dismay seeing that the Owlape Grand Vizier was planning to use the language of the contract I signed with the Demon Merchant Code to enter the Realm of True Evil to argue that I was guilty of both counts.
Having already guessed the Owlapes might make this argument, I answered politely. "Grand Vizier, note the wording: ’bound by honor.’ It does not say ’bound by law.’ It names no penalty and no remedy. Your family wrote a clause that sounds like a commandment but carries no force, and then charged me for ignoring it."
The Grand Vizier’s big owl eyes widened. He had realized that I not only knew of the clause but was prepared to argue against it, and he began to suspect that my actions were premeditated rather than opportunistic. After all, he only gave the latter one hour to prepare for the hearing. He couldn’t have known they would use this one against him... might sure, but certainly not.
Knowing this did not weaken his argument, so he pushed back. "The clause is absolute. No merchant is exempt from it."
"Absolute in tone, yes. Enforceable, no. A rule that carries no consequence is a request, however loudly it is spoken," I said with a smug grin. "Does the Mulias Imperial Family make a habit of using this clause to compel every merchant entering the Realm of True Evil to fully reveal their haul? No, because everyone knows this clause is merely a suggestion resting on the shoulders of honor and good faith. By not abiding by it, all I did was show that I lacked honor and good faith toward the Mulias Imperial Family. If anything, that is the only consequence the clause carries. It is enforced by social morals, and most certainly not by law. This clause is in no way applicable, even if it were I’m not guilty on either of the counts."
"The respondent cannot sign a contract, take its benefits, and then call its terms ornamental," the Grand Vizier said, his stern gaze unmoving. "Honor was the standard because honor is the currency of merchants. He spent it, and now he disputes the debt."
Despite my making clear that morality was not the same as legality, the Owlape continued to insist on his argument. It was plain that, whatever I said, the Grand Vizier meant to bury his head in the sand and repeat the same nonsense.
So I snapped back, "Is the respondent being serious? Have I not already stated that, at most, it proves I lack honor and acted without good faith toward the Mulias Imperial Family? Besides, we are Demon Merchants. We have no honor to begin with.
"Name one realm that deals with Demon Merchants trusting our honor and not out of their desperate necessity. The Demon Merchants’ modus operandi has always been to use honor as a tool to secure the best deal for ourselves at the client’s expense. Talking about honor does not suit you, Grand Vizier. May I remind the Court that this entire contract was bait, meant to lure merchants into the Realm of True Evil in hopes of making off with a fortune for nothing?
"Now that I have swallowed the bait without falling into your trap, you try to ensnare me with words like honor? A Demon Merchant and a Devil Merchant arguing over honor, if the others in the Myriad Realms were to hear it, they would have a good laugh hard enough to go grave early.
"Therefore, I advise you, Grand Vizier, to stop beating around the bush and get to the point. I ask you not to waste both our precious time."
The Grand Vizier’s feathers trembled, not from emotional turmoil but from the sudden joy of hearing me admit to acting in bad faith. Back on Earth, I would have lost the hearing already and been sentenced without a trial. However, this was not a democratic world’s court but the Demon Merchant Code’s court.
Well, his joy was a gift. It let the charade continue long enough for me to learn what I wanted from him. I was that confident about winning the hearing. My problem was never the hearing itself but getting the answer I sought from it. To do that, I needed the Owlape to become recklessly confident, just as I was pretending to be right now, and the only way he would reach that point was by believing he would win. The reaction of his feathers told me he did.
"Let the record reflect," he said, his stern gaze fixed on the radiant ceiling, "that the respondent has confessed to lacking honor and good faith, and has described the contract as bait he knowingly took. The appellant asks no more than this: that the respondent be held to what he admitted."